Healthy Cottage Cheese Chocolate Protein Pudding Parfait

This cottage cheese pudding recipe started when my husband asked if I could make high-protein snacks or desserts for him to enjoy at night. Unlike me, he inherited a super-fast metabolism. While he does work out a lot, he’s always hungry, loves to eat healthy, and is constantly looking for protein-rich recipes that will keep him full while providing essential nutrients.

One day, he mentioned wanting to try a cottage cheese pudding he saw on Reddit. He came home with a big tub of cottage cheese and cocoa powder, ready to experiment. He told me what he was about to do, and I sat on the kitchen stool, practicing self-control as I watched him mix cottage cheese with unsweetened cocoa powder. Oh, and it got worse—he added ice water to the mix because it wouldn’t blend properly.

Now, I’m not a control freak—unless it involves watching someone struggle in the kitchen while silently screaming, “Don’t do that!” in my mind. I wanted to let him do this on his own, but after one bite, he knew he had messed up. That’s when I jumped off the stool and said, “LET ME DO IT!”When I made my butternut squash brownies a few weeks ago, the batter tasted a lot like pudding. I knew exactly how I wanted to approach this cottage cheese pudding recipe, and after a few ingredient adjustments, it turned out absolutely perfect. It tastes like the creamiest, richest mousse you’d find on the dessert menu at a fancy restaurant. The cocoa powder cures any sweet tooth cravings, the cottage cheese is completely hidden, and the maple syrup perfectly balances the bitterness of the rich chocolate. Oh my goodness, this chocolate protein pudding is a real treat—and a healthy one, too! My husband couldn’t believe how good it was, so I made even more and packed them into the cutest jars to keep in the refrigerator. I have never been a fan of chocolates mixed with Greek yogurt, so I love that cottage cheese offers the same benefits without the sour taste. 

More Healthy Snack Recipes:

Healthy Double Chocolate Cookies with Almond Flour Recipe
Almond Flour Chocolate Chip Cookies | A Healthier Cookie
Hidden Fruit & Veggie Oat Muffins | Toddler Approved
Roasted Honey Cinnamon Mixed Nut & Cherry Oat Granola
Chickpea Peanut Butter Blender Blondies | Toddler Approved
5-Ingredient No-Bake Chocolate Hazelnut Protein Balls
Dragon Fruit & Chia Almond No-Bake Protein Energy Balls
Homemade Cookie Dough Protein Bars | Gluten & Diary Free
Copycat Homemade Whole Food’s Granola Bar Recipe
4-Ingredient, No-Bake, Chocolate Chip Protein Breakfast Balls (gluten free & dairy free)
Fudgy Avocado Brownies (Gluten, Sugar & Dairy Free)
Carbless Chocolate Peanut Butter Pecan Bark
Homemade Healthy Green Juice Gummy Bears
Lemon Blackberry Protein Muffins – Gluten-Free & Dairy Free
4-Ingredient Pumpkin Spice Energy Bites | vegan, gluten free

Healthy Cottage Cheese Chocolate Protein Pudding Parfait Ingredients:

• Cottage Cheese (I recommend using regular, not low fat, for the best texture and flavor)
• Almond Butter (Almond butter and cashew butter are the mildest-flavored nut butter for this recipe, but you can also use peanut butter or sunflower butter)
• Maple Syrup (The maple flavor is invisible in this recipe, but you can substitute with honey, date syrup, or agave if preferred)
• Unsweetened Cocoa Powder (For rich chocolate flavor without added sugars)
• Sea Salt (To enhance the chocolate taste)
• Vanilla Extract (For a hint of warmth and depth)

This combination creates a delicious and nutritious chocolate protein pudding parfait that’s both high in protein and low in added sugars.

You can also customize this recipe with a few extra ingredients to boost protein content or add health benefits:

• Espresso Powder (Optional for an extra boost of flavor)
• Your Favorite Protein Powder (For added protein content and flavor)
• Collagen Peptides (Optional for additional protein and gut health benefits)
• Spinach (Optional, to sneak in some greens without altering the flavor)
  
• Chia Seeds (For added fiber, omega-3 fatty acids, and a satisfying texture)
• Flaxseeds (For additional fiber, healthy fats, and a nutty flavor)

This recipe’s texture is identical to the chocolate pudding you get in the little cups at the grocery store, but it’s so much better for you. After growing up eating only processed foods, I’m trying my best to make better options for my family (without drawing too much attention to them).

Why healthy cottage cheese chocolate protein pudding is so much better than the typical store-bought pudding:

• High Sugar Content: Many contain high amounts of added sugars or artificial sweeteners.
• Artificial Additives: They often include artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives.
• Low Nutritional Value: These puddings typically lack essential nutrients and can be low in protein, fiber, and healthy fats.
• High in Saturated Fats: Some commercial puddings use unhealthy fats like hydrogenated oils or high levels of processed cream.
• Refined Ingredients: Many contain refined ingredients like refined flour and high-fructose corn syrup, which offer little nutritional value.
• Lack of Protein: Store-bought puddings often have minimal protein.

Watch the healthy chocolate cottage cheese protein pudding video tutorial below to see how easy this recipe is!

The cottage cheese texture and flavor are invisible in this recipe! I promise you’ll be just as shocked as I was after the first bite.
 
I found these plastic reusable jars on Amazon (linked in my storefront), and I’ve been using them to make homemade nut butter, hummus, and granola. They are so cute and practical, and I love that they aren’t glass—toddlers and glass do not mix! They’re also the perfect size, too!

I kept this parfait pretty simple, but you can customize it with fun toppings like crushed graham crackers, granola, extra fruit, chocolate chips, or any other additions you like. I bet a cherry pie filling would be delicious with the chocolate pudding!

I can’t wait for you to try this recipe! Please come back and let me know what you think! This will not be the end of my cottage cheese recipe series. I have so many more ideas!

Questions for you!

1. What flavor combo should I try to make next?
2. What do you look for when picking out snacks?
3. Have you ever tried using cottage cheese in sweet recipes?

love this recipe? Try the pumpkin pie spice pudding!