Home » Recipes ByTaralynn February 26, 2026 Oatmeal Cream Pies CLICK HERE TO GET THE RECIPE FOR THESE OATMEAL CREAM PIES! Pinterest Facebook CopyCopied 392Shares Keep Up with Taralynn Next Post >The Best Apple Crisp Recipe
I made these for Thanksgiving and they were a hit! I can’t wait to make more of your recipes! Thank you! Reply
Wow these look so delicious! I love oatmeal anything, so I can’t wait to try these out 🙂 http://www.justbeingbrooklyn.com Reply
Hi Taralynn! I wanted to make these this weekend and was wondering how long they last. Do you refrigerate them? Reply
You can:) I left mine out. They didn’t last more than a day with everyone who ate them! But they should be good for a week! 🙂 Keep them in a baggy! Reply
I just made these tonight. All I can say is….OH…MY…GOSH. I will NEVER eat another store bought creme pie EVER again. They’re amazing!!! Thank you for sharing!!! Reply
These look so good!! Any suggestions for a dairy alternative to the butter? Do you think ghee would work the same? Thanks! Reply
Sounds super yummy! Do you know what the calorie content is for these?
I made these for Thanksgiving and they were a hit! I can’t wait to make more of your recipes! Thank you!
So glad you liked them!!!
Oh my gosh… these look/sound amazing! I love Oatmeal Crème pies!
They are so so so so good!:)
Is Marshmallow Creme the same thing as Fluff?
Yes!:) Marshmallow fluff too!
Wow these look so delicious! I love oatmeal anything, so I can’t wait to try these out 🙂
http://www.justbeingbrooklyn.com
Enjoy!!
Hello! Will baking on parchment paper work ok? You do you prefer the aluminum foil?
Hi Britta! I just baked the straight on the pan! 🙂
Hi Taralynn!
I wanted to make these this weekend and was wondering how long they last. Do you refrigerate them?
You can:) I left mine out. They didn’t last more than a day with everyone who ate them! But they should be good for a week! 🙂 Keep them in a baggy!
I just made these tonight. All I can say is….OH…MY…GOSH. I will NEVER eat another store bought creme pie EVER again. They’re amazing!!! Thank you for sharing!!!
So glad you love them Angela!!!!!! xo
Can you make these a day in advanced? If so, how would you store them?
Yes! Keep them in the fridge or on the counter in a plastic baggy!
Just made these! They are very rich, but delicious!
They really are 🙂
These were the best freaking cookies in the world!
Aren’t they!? 😉
These look so good!! Any suggestions for a dairy alternative to the butter? Do you think ghee would work the same? Thanks!
Planning to make these for Thanksgiving. How many cookies does this recipe make?
Can I make these with Quick Oats instead of Old Fashioned?
You can